What’s a Reservation of Rights, and How Does It Affect My Insurance Claim?

What is a reservation of rights, and do I have a conflict of interest with my insurance?

When an insurance company agrees to defend an insured party against a claim, they may do so under a “reservation of rights.” This means that the insurer agrees to defend the insured, but reserves the right to later deny coverage if it is determined that the claim is not covered by the insurance policy.

In other words, the insurer is providing a defense to the insured while reserving the right to later determine that the claim is not covered by the policy and therefore not pay any damages that may be awarded.

The reason an insurer might issue a reservation of rights is because the insurer believes that there is a possibility that the claim may not be covered by the policy. This could be because the policy does not cover the specific type of claim being made, or because the insured party failed to meet certain requirements under the policy, such as reporting the claim in a timely manner.

How can Cumis counsel protect my interests in an insurance claim?

When an insurer issues a reservation of rights, it is important for the insured party to understand the potential implications. If the insurer ultimately determines that the claim is not covered by the policy, the insured may be responsible for paying any damages awarded in the claim, as well as the costs of their defense. This is why the right to obtain independent counsel under a Cumis counsel arrangement can be so important. The insured party can hire their own attorney to represent them and protect their interests, even if those interests conflict with those of the insurer.

“Cumis counsel” refers to independent counsel appointed by an insurance company to represent an insured party when there is a conflict of interest between the insured and the insurer. Under California Civil Procedure Code section 2860, when an insurance policy requires the insurer to defend an insured party against a claim, and the insurer reserves the right to deny coverage or defend the claim under a reservation of rights, the insured party has the right to retain independent counsel of their choice to defend them. This is known as “Cumis counsel.”

The term “Cumis counsel” comes from the California court case, San Diego Federal Credit Union v. Cumis Insurance Society, Inc. (1984), which established the right of an insured to select independent counsel when a conflict of interest arises between the insured and the insurer.

The purpose of Cumis counsel is to ensure that the insured’s interests are protected – even if they conflict with the interests of the insurer. The insurer is required to pay for the reasonable fees and expenses of Cumis counsel, subject to certain limitations.

If your insurance company is agreeing to defend your claim under a reservation of rights and you believe that you may have a conflict with your own insurance company, you may want to consider the possibility of getting your insurance to provide you with Cumis counsel. Please call the attorneys at Gallagher Krich APC at (858) 926-5797 or contact “info [at] tomgallagherlaw.com” today for further information.

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. The responsible managing attorney is Tom Gallagher. This blog post is for informational purposes of California law for legal matters in the State of California only and should not be construed as legal advice or an attorney-client relationship which requires a written fee agreement. All communications with our firm are private and confidential and the substance of those communications should not be discussed with others. 

Latest News & Updates

Meet Our San Diego Attorneys

Thomas F. Gallagher, Esq.

Partner

(858) 926-5797
tom [at] tomgallagherlaw.com

Troy B. Krich, Esq.

Partner

(858) 926-5797
troy [at] tomgallagherlaw.com

Contact Gallagher Krich, APC

What Clients Say:

Mike K., Google

August 11, 2023

Thank you so much for all your help in resolving a real estate matter so quickly and efficiently.

Mike K
Verified

What Clients Say:

Veronica D., Yelp

October 17, 2023

We had the pleasure of speaking with Troy for a contractor issue we had recently. He is smart, patient, empathetic and basically the lawyer we would want to be our side for (may God forbids) any legal assistance or battle we need! The interaction we had with him was “free of charge” but we already felt his dedication and concern (he took the time to reach out and follow up on how he can assist us further) which busy lawyers would normally ask their admin or assistant to do so on their behalf. We will be sure to contact again Troy, if need be! Thank you!!

Veronica D

What Clients Say:

Daniel E., Google

October 11, 2022

I left a voicemail for Tom late Sunday evening and received a phone call first thing the next morning.

Tom was very quick to reply to any questions I had, and if he was caught up in a meeting, he was sure to return my call promptly.

Tom provided sound and logical advice, during a very stressful and uncertain time. At times I asked him to be more aggressive and was often met with the pros and cons of that decision, allowing me to understand the approach and thought process behind his strategy.

Ultimately he provided options for several paths for us to take, worked swiftly, and got us where we needed to be.

He reached out several times to check on my sanity and make sure I was good.

As someone with very high expectations, I would highly recommend his services. He provided expertise that proved to be successful, and also took the time to make sure I was emotionally solid.

Tom assisted with me with a 50% / 50% ownership conflict.

Daniel E
Verified

What Clients Say:

Deanna, LawConnect.com

February 23, 2022

Really informative and actionable, very grateful to have connected and I look forward to working more with them in the future.

Deanna
Verified

What Clients Say:

Marilyn, LawConnect.com

February 8, 2022

i liked that a lawyer, and not a staff member, called me to get the details and he gave me his opinion of what his initial thoughts are about my case.

Marilyn
Verified

What Clients Say:

Bob W., Google

August 30, 2021

What was thought to be a simple breach of contract turned into a nightmare. Through their tenacity and their deep knowledge of the law, we were successful. There is no reason to look any further as you will not get any better representation than this firm. I highly recommend them and strongly suggest that if you are considering starting a business or are already managing one, this firm will guide you, avoiding the troubled waters businesses sometimes find themselves in.

Bob W
Verified

What Clients Say:

Rasmita M., Google

August 13, 2021

Johnny Nitti helped us with our estate plan. He was very meticulous while drafting the plan and spent enough time to explain the details to us. He filed the deed with county recorder and paid for the fees himself. Overall, Johnny did a great job and we definitely plan to work with him in the future for any updates to our EP.

Rasmita M
Verified

What Clients Say:

George A., Google

August 6, 2021

Johnny Nitti helped me with my estate planning (will, living trust, etc.) and made the process smooth. He is very responsive and organized. I highly recommend contacting Johnny.

George A
Verified

What Clients Say:

Ashley C., Google

July 18, 2020

Tom Gallagher is very knowledgeable and helpful when it comes to business law. I reached out to him reguarding the Pandemic and my salon and I’m so glad I did. Many times stress and hard times can fog clarity and he really helped me understand the laws.

Thanks Tom!!!

Ashley C
Verified

What Clients Say:

Evan D., Google

July 16, 2019

Thank you Troy for everything! Professional, prompt, and smooth handling of my case. I will be recommending to anyone that is in need of a lawyer.

Evan D
Verified